Key testimony in Daniel Penny manslaughter trial focuses on chokeholds
Judge Jeanine Pirro has the latest on 'America Reports' on testimony from an instructor who taught the accused Marine vet chokeholds and a pivotal witness who admitted lying.
NEW YORK CITY – A Manhattan forensic pathologist who conducted the autopsy on Jordan Neely after he died following an aggressive outburst on a New York City subway car testified Friday that Neely had synthetic drugs in his system when he died but had been killed by asphyxiation.
Dr. Cynthia Harris of the City Medical Examiner’s Office tesified during the manslaughter trial of Marine veteran Daniel Penny, 26.
She said she had ruled the 30-year-old Neely’s cause of death to have been asphyxia from compression to his neck. The toxicology report showed he also had drugs in his system, although she said she could identify them broadly as "a synthetic cannabinoid," but not in specific terms or at what dose.
"We found in the blood a synthetic cannabinoid – a relatively new drug in the scheme of drugs," she said. "They’re synthetic and more potent than marijuana. In a class of drugs, they fall under the category of stimulants – they rev the body up, fall into the same class of drugs as, say, cocaine."
DANIEL PENNY TRIAL RESUMES AS FELLOW MARINE VET EXPLAINS CHOKEHOLD TRAINING ON WITNESS STAND
Daniel Penny arrives for his trial at the Manhattan Criminal Court building in New York City on Friday, Nov. 15, 2024. Penny, a Marine veteran, is charged with second-degree manslaughter and criminally negligent homicide in the 2023 death of Jordan Neely on a New York City subway train. (Adam Gray for Fox News Digital)
There was no damage to bones in his chin, neck or midline structures, she said. She found scrapes and bruises on his face, neck, torso and arms, petechiae (small red spots caused by bleeding) in his eyes and damage to his spleen from sickle cell trait.
Prosecutors played video of the chokehold again and Dr. Harris commented as she went through it.
At one point, she said he was conversing, showing that he had "air moving through his vocal chords." She described Neely straining to breathe and making hand gestures, which she said were a signal for help.
Assistant District Attorney Dafna Yoran asked about witnesses testifying that Neely hadn’t gagged or gasped or said that he couldn’t breathe.
"Sometimes people make noises when they can't breathe, and sometimes they don’t," she replied.
Cynthia Harris, M.D. arrives for Daniel Penny’s trial at the Manhattan Criminal Court building in New York City on Friday, Nov. 15, 2024. Penny, a Marine veteran, is charged with second-degree manslaughter and criminally negligent homicide in the 2023 death of Jordan Neely on a New York City subway train. (Adam Gray for Fox News Digital)
She also said that she believes that Neely died around two minutes, nine seconds into the video, after his face turned purple and he began "twitching" in death throes.
"I believe that at this point he has lost consciousness, and what we will see in the form of these twitchings represents brain injury," she said.
Under cross-examination she later said she couldn't tell his time of death from the video.
"I can't tell you when exactly he died, philosophically, but the video is of a man dying," she said.
Penny is on trial for the May 1, 2023, death of Neely, a homeless man with a lengthy criminal record and history of mental illness who stormed onto the train and started making death threats, according to witnesses.
As he screamed about going to prison for life, raised his fists and lunged at people, Penny grabbed him in a headlock and wrestled him to the ground. Other riders helped hold him down as they waited for police to arrive. Neely died.
Dr. Harris' testimony began Thursday, after Joseph Caballer, the Marine martial arts instructor who had taught Penny about chokeholds, told the jury that the point of the maneuver is to take control of a threat until they are unconscious.
Caballer explained the difference between blood chokes and air chokes – moves that alternately deprive the aggressor of bloodflow to and from the brain or oxygen. Dr. Harris described on Friday what she had seen in the video.
Joseph Caballer exits Manhattan Supreme Court in New York City on Thursday, Nov. 14, 2024. The 30-year-old former Marine testified at the trial of Daniel Penny in the chokehold death of Jordan Neely on a New York City subway in May 2023. (Adam Gray for Fox News Digital)
"If you only compress the vein, but you have not applied enough force to compress the artery, there are a few things you see when that happens," she said. "You become congested or purple in color. The veins become distended, because they’re full of blood. If the pressure continues, then the capillaries develop pools of blood or petechiae."
She had the ADA stop the video and said that she sees that the veins in Neely’s face are distended and his face appears purple, much darker than the skin on his arms.
Under cross examination from Penny defense attorney, Steven Raiser, Dr. Harris said acknowledged that a colleague found the petechiae to be small and "not conclusive." She agreed that it would be fair to say that the small petechiae isn’t a direct sign that death was caused by a chokehold.
The initial finding on May 2, 2023, was that the cause of death was "pending further study." Then she made a decision after seeing the chokehold video, she said.
"I based my decision on the autopsy findings coupled with the video," she said. "I didn’t wait for toxicology, because no toxicological report would change my opinion. He could have come back with enough fentanyl to kill an elephant and walked onto the train and got put in a chokehold, and that’s how he died."
Demonstrators hold up a Michael Jackson-style jacket to represent Jordan Neely at the Manhattan Criminal Court building in New York City on Friday, Nov. 15, 2024. Daniel Penny, a Marine veteran, is charged with second-degree manslaughter and criminally negligent homicide in the 2023 death of Neely on a New York City subway train. Neely was a former Jackson impersonator. (Adam Gray for Fox News Digital)
Although Neely still had a pulse after Penny let go, Dr. Harris said that wasn't unusual.
"This is an asphyxial death," she said. "In an asphyxia death, the brain dies first. It’s deprived of oxygen. Other tissues and organs in the body are not as sensitive as the brain. They too will die, but the brain dies first."
According to case notes introduced into evidence, Neely's death was initially suspected to be from cardiac arrest, and he had "no visible trauma."
During her testimony, Dr. Harris referred to the manner of death as homicide, and the defense objected. The judge ordered those comments stricken from the record.
She also said that the synthetic drugs in Neely's system "would not help the heart" during a struggle.
Dr. Harris returned Friday morning to pick up where she left off when court adjourned the day before.
The prosecution was expected to rest its case after her testimony. Penny's defense team are expected to call their first witness Monday – but Dr. Harris will return to the stand for a third day of testimony first.
On Tuesday, a man who appeared on video helping Penny hold Neely down testified.
Eric Gonzales told the court that at one point he said Penny hadn't held Neely tightly enough, that he had felt a pulse when they both finally let go, that he had been granted immunity from prosecution in exchange for testifying – and that he had initially lied to investigators.
This undated photo, provided by Mills and Edwards, LLP, in New York, Friday, May 12, 2023, shows Jordan Neely, left, with Carolyn Neely, an aunt. (Courtesy Mills & Edwards, LLP via AP)
CLICK HERE TO GET THE FOX NEWS APP
Penny faces up to 15 years in prison if convicted of the more serious charge of manslaughter.
He also faces a count of criminally negligent homicide.
True Crime
The hottest stories ripped from the headlines, from crime to courts, legal and scandal.
By entering your email and clicking the Subscribe button, you agree to the Fox News Privacy Policy and Terms of Use, and agree to receive content and promotional communications from Fox News. You understand that you can opt-out at any time.
